Questions and Topics for Your Blog Posting:
1. For each video and article list/discuss the key concepts you learned.
2. Which philosopher's theory on aesthetics do you feel is most important? Be sure to mention
the philosophers name, era (time in history), and contribution to the aesthetic theory in your
response.
3. What do you think about Changeux and Ramachandran scientific view of aesthetics and art?
What was the most interesting fact you discovered from each speakers lecture?
4. How do the videos and article relate to the readings in the text?
5. What is your opinion of the films and article? How do they add depth to understanding of the
topics in your reading in the text?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. One of the key concepts that I have learned is from Arthur C. Danto a professor at Columbia
university making the statement of what makes something a work of art? What is the
difference from everything else? this to be the beginning question when you are looking at
something to define what it actually is classified as. Art in era of B.C. was not viewed as
something aesthetically pleasing but rather looked down upon from philosophers especially
from Plato. He thought poorly of artists and poets because of the “fact” that their works of art
were just imperfect copies of the real objects and were speaking of things that were untrue
or unrealistic in the mind of a philosopher. Alexander Baumgarten famously coined the word
of aesthetic and its meaning. When it came to Changeux and Ramachandran’s lecture I
found it really interesting how evolution played a role in the works of art. How the origin and
the capacity of the brain allowed artists to only create what could have been allowed by
their capacity of knowledge and surroundings. I really found it strange and amusing that art
is a “lie.” The artist create his piece of work by what he or she perceives to be the truth and
we as an audience will either buy into that work of art or we will disapprove of the work
created. It is the job of the artist to make us believe that it is believable and acceptable that
the sky is painted green for example and that the tree is very unrealistic in its line drawings
but if the artist can make us see the whole picture and trick us into thinking that work is
actually a reflection from the sky to the ground then they have pulled off the truth.
2. Francis Hutcheson form 18th century stated, “Ideas brought about in our soul by beauty and
harmony delight us necessarily and immediately, just like the other sensible ideas.” I feel
that this is really important because due to Plato giving artists a really a really poor
reputation and discredited their work it brought life back into artists work when being viewed
by others. Artists were on the rise and were given credit for their work by Aristotle creating a
book of poetics which showed how art was indeed for a fact constructed but with this quote
from Hutcheson it opened a new door in the viewing of art. Individuals were now not just
seeing the beauty but could related to it on a personal level and bring joy to their lives
based off of what they were able to see and interpret from what they were able to view the
work of art as.
3. From Changeux and Ramachandran’s scientific view of aesthetics and art lecture I found the
most interesting fact to be related to the brain. Work’s of art has made progression in detail
as the decades went on from the level of being able to comprehend and the advances in
tools. Individuals in the earliest forms of art created were only able to make stick and line
drawings because that is all that their brains to handle and allow the artists to create along
with the tools used which were usually stones. As the mind started to advance over the
decades and brain capacity was increasing details and new forms of art were able to
generate as well as the tools that could create the art.
4. The videos and article relate to the readings in the text by giving us a visual example of
works of art form that time, to pictures of philosophers, in-depth meanings behind the
decades of why art is created, the time history from where the beginning of art was created
up to modern day, and the history of how we got to works of art in this day and age.
5. I really enjoyed watching the films and reading the CNN article. It really added depth in the
fact of how humans created art and how through the era’s were able to expand their
capacity of the brain and increase their methods in creating their works of art and the
appreciation levels growing as the era’s went by.
http://fod.infobase.com/p_ViewPlaylist.aspx?AssignmentID=M27YLB